Email Alert | RSS    帮助

中国防痨杂志 ›› 2013, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (10): 793-798.

• 论著 • 上一篇    下一篇

不同发现策略应用于老年肺结核患者发现的成本效果研究

张灿有 王黎霞 张慧 成君   

  1. 102206 北京,中国疾病预防控制中心结核病预防控制中心国际合作与研究部(张灿有、成君),主任办公室(王黎霞、张慧)
  • 收稿日期:2013-07-31 出版日期:2013-10-10 发布日期:2014-01-03
  • 通信作者: 成君 E-mail:chengjun@chinatb.org
  • 基金资助:

    “十二五”国家科技重大专项“结核病流行与干预模式研究”课题(2013ZX10003-004)

Cost-effectiveness study of different strategies for pulmonary tuberculosis case finding in elderly people

ZHANG Can-you, WANG Li-xia, ZHANG Hui, CHENG Jun   

  1. Department of International Cooperation and Research, National Center for Tuberculosis Control and Prevention, Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Beijing 102206, China
  • Received:2013-07-31 Online:2013-10-10 Published:2014-01-03
  • Contact: CHENG Jun E-mail:chengjun@chinatb.org

摘要: 目的 通过研究肺结核患者不同发现策略的成本-效果,确定在老年人中开展肺结核患者发现的最优策略,为卫生决策者制定肺结核患者发现策略提供科学依据。方法 采用决策树法对老年人使用不同诊断技术组合进行肺结核患者发现的成本效果进行分析,得到一种最优策略。假设有一个50万人口的全人群,其中的老年人(≥60岁)是本研究的目标人群。使用TreeAge ProSuite 2011软件建立决策树模型,包括3种策略:(1)策略1:对目标人群中主动就诊的可疑症状者进行胸部X线检查和痰涂片萋尼染色镜检。(2)策略2:对目标人群先进行线索调查,对线索调查发现的肺结核可疑症状者进行胸部X线检查和痰涂片萋尼染色镜检。(3)策略3:对目标人群先询问症状,并做胸部X线检查;对有临床表现或X线检查怀疑肺结核者做痰涂片萋尼染色检查。收集参数和参数敏感度分析范围,进行成本-效果分析确定最优策略,进行敏感度分析检验模型的稳定性。结果 对全体老年人先询问症状和X线胸片检查,任何一项异常做痰涂片,即策略3,是在老年人中进行患者发现的最大效果策略,能够发现713肺结核患者;对主动就诊的老年可疑症状者做X线胸片和痰涂片检查(策略1)为最高效率策略,每发现一例肺结核患者花费551元;敏感度分析显示各参数在设定的范围内变化不影响模型分析的结果。结论 为了发现更多的肺结核患者,老年人群应采用策略3;为了实现最高效的肺结核患者发现,老年人群应采用策略1;现阶段,对老年人单独开展肺结核患者发现不符合成本-效益原则,未来可以考虑在具有多重危险因素的人群中做进一步的研究。

关键词: 结核, 肺/经济学, 费用效益分析, 决策树, 老年人

Abstract: Objective To optimize strategies for pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) case finding in elderly people through cost-effectinveness analyses, and provide scientific evidences of such cases finding strategies for policy maker in China. Methods Using decision tree to conduct cost-effectiveness analysis of different straregies which are used for finding PTB patients, then to get an optimal strategy. It is assumed that there is a crowd of 500000 people, and the elderly people(≥60 years old) of it are the target group in this study. Using sofeware TreeAge ProSuite 2011 to build decision tree models, including 3 strategies: (1) For the elderly people who have PTB symptoms and can see a doctor actively: chest X-ray and sputum smear microscopy should be taken. (2)Firstly, clue investigation should be taken to the target groups. And then, chest X-ray and sputum smear microscopy may be given to those who are symptomatic candidates going to clinic actively and from clue investigation. (3) For all the elderly people: firstly, symptom screening and chest X-ray should be taken. And then, sputum smear microscopy may be given to those who have clinical manifestation or have been suspected pulmonary tuberculosis by chest X-ray. To collect parameters and scopes of the parameters, carry out cost-effectiveness analyses to confirm the optimal strategy, and carry out sensitivity analyses to check out the stability of the models. Results Strategy 3 (For all the elderly people: firstly, symptom screening and chest X-ray should be taken. And then, sputum smear microscopy may be given to those who have clinical manifestation or have been suspected pulmonary tuberculosis by chest X-ray) was the most productive one for PTB case finding, which could find 713 PTB patients; strategy 1(For the elderly people who have PTB symptoms and can see a doctor: chest X-ray and sputum smear microscopy should be taken) was the most efficient one, which would cost 551 Yuan for one PTB patient. The sensitivity analyses showed that the results of the model analyses were not affected by the scopes of the parameters. Conclusion To find more PTB patients, case finding in elderly people should strategy 3. To be most efficient, case finding should take strategy 1 in elderly people. By now, it is not fit to the cost-effectiveness principle to finding PTB patients in elderly people all alone. It may be considered to do research in groups with multiple risks in future.

Key words: Tuberculosis, pulmonary/economics, Cost-benefit analysis, Decision trees, Aged