Email Alert | RSS    帮助

中国防痨杂志 ›› 2014, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (5): 308-312.doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-6621.2014.05.002

• 论著 • 上一篇    下一篇

不同筹资模式119例耐多药结核病患者未纳入项目治疗的原因分析

阮云洲 李仁忠 赵津 苏伟 成君 张灿有 王黎霞 郝阳   

  1. 102206  北京,中国疾病预防控制中心结核病预防控制中心耐药防治部(阮云洲、李仁忠、赵津、苏伟、成君、张灿有、王黎霞);人民卫生出版社办公室(郝阳)
  • 收稿日期:2014-03-12 出版日期:2014-05-10 发布日期:2014-06-07
  • 通信作者: 郝阳 E-mail:haoyang@moh.gov.cn
  • 基金资助:

    “十一五”国家重大科技专项(2008ZX10003-007);全球基金中国结核病控制项目(TB09-002)

The analysis of 119 cases of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis patients not enrolling for proper treatment in different financing models

RUAN Yun-zhou, LI Ren-zhong, ZHAO Jin, SU Wei, CHENG Jun, ZHANG Can-you, WANG Li-xia, HAO Yang   

  1. Department of Drug-resistant Tuberculosis Control of National Center for Tuberculosis Control and Prevention, Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Beijing 102206, China
  • Received:2014-03-12 Online:2014-05-10 Published:2014-06-07
  • Contact: HAO Yang E-mail:haoyang@moh.gov.cn

摘要: 目的 探索和描述耐多药结核病患者未纳入项目治疗的比例及其原因。方法 “十一五”国家重大科技专项课题组在不同筹资模式的5个研究地区(免费治疗点:黑龙江省大庆市、浙江省衢州市、河南省濮阳市;仅药品免费治疗点:天津市;患者自付治疗点:重庆市万州区),选择2010年3月1日至2012年2月29日期间,经传统药敏试验确诊的全部耐多药结核病患者235例作为研究对象。邀请不同领域专家设计半结构式问卷,通过预调查进行修改和完善,内容包括患者姓名、性别、年龄、职业、收入、登记分类、是否纳入项目治疗、未纳入项目治疗原因(经济原因、身体原因、患者顾虑、交通原因、医生态度、医生判断、不可抗因素、其他)等15项内容,由受过培训的医务人员,以面对面或电话访谈患者的方式填写。填写完毕经与患者病历记录复核、以及与当地社区医生或知情者印证后收回。共发出问卷235份,经现场复核后收回有效问卷235份。 结果  确诊的235例耐多药结核病患者中,未纳入项目治疗者119例,未纳入项目治疗者占50.6%。不同筹资模式的地区未纳入项目治疗的比率分别为:免费治疗点39.0%(46/118),仅药品免费治疗点50.0%(25/50),患者自付治疗点71.6%(48/67),诊疗费用减免程度越高,未纳入项目治疗的比例越低(线性趋势检验,χ2=17.809,P<0.01)。未纳入项目治疗的原因中,免费点主要为死亡(37.0%,17/46)、主观拒绝(21.7%,10/46)、失去联系(17.4%,8/46);仅药品免费点主要为失去联系(64.0%,16/25)、迁出(外地治疗)(16.0%,4/25)和主观拒绝(12.0%,3/25);自付点主要是经济困难(33.3%,16/48)、死亡(22.9%,11/48)和失去联系(16.7%,8/48),不同筹资模式耐多药结核病患者未纳入项目治疗原因差异有统计学意义(χ2=62.326,P=0.000)。不同筹资模式的各种未纳入项目治疗的原因中,需要解决的重点不同:免费点为主观拒绝和失去联系、仅药品免费点为失去联系、自付点为经济困难和失去联系,分别可以减少39.1%(18/46)、64.0%(16/25)和50.0%(24/48)的未纳入项目治疗比例。 结论  耐多药结核病患者未纳入项目治疗比率随着诊疗费用减免幅度的增加而下降;除医疗费用引起的经济困难外,研究提示未纳入项目治疗还可能与失去联系、等待诊断过程中的死亡、主观拒绝、严重合并症等多种原因有关。

关键词: 结核, 肺, 结核, 抗多种药物性, 资本筹集, 费用, 医疗, 患者拒绝治疗

Abstract: Objective  To explore and describe the proportion and the reasons for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis patients nonparticipation of proper treatment. Methods  Five prefectures (Daqing of Heilongjiang, Quzhou of Zhejiang, Puyang of He’nan, Tianjin, Wanzhou of Chongqing) with different financing models were selected as settings by specialists panel of the key national science and technology program. Two hundred and thirty five MDR-TB patients confirmed by traditional DST between Mar 1st, 2010 and Feb 29th, 2012 were selected as study objects. All of them received face to face or telephone interview by the trained professionals with half-structured questionnaire including individual information (such as name, gender, age, occupation, income, notification classification, whether enrolled or not) and reasons of nonparticipation (financial risk, health, concerns, transportation, attitude and judgment of doctors, others).  Results  Proportion of patients not enrolled varied by financing models. The non-enrollment proportions were 39.0%(46/118), 50.0%(25/50)and 71.6%(48/67)respectively(χ2=17.809,P<0.01) in all-free model, only free for drugs model, and all paid by patients model. The main reason of nonparticipation of all-free model is death(37.0%,17/46), refusing enrollment(21.7%,10/46), loss of contact(17.4%,8/46); of only free for drugs model is loss of contact(64.0%,16/25), transfer-out(16.0%,4/25), refusing enrollment(12.0%,3/25); of paid all by patients model is economic difficulties(33.3%,16/48), death(22.9%,11/48), loss of contact(16.7%,8/48)(χ2=62.326,P=0.000). The reasons for non-enrollment are significantly different by models. The non-enrollment proportion could reduce 39.1%(18/46), 64.0%(16/25) and 50.0%(24/48) respectively if we could solve refusing and loss of contact issue in all-free model, loss of contact in only free for drug model and economic difficulties and loss of contact for all paid by patients model.  Conclusion  Proportion of nonparticipation for proper treatment of MDR-TB cases will decline with the increase of the scope of free treatment. In addition to the economic difficulties, the study shows that nonparticipation may also relate to other reasons like loss of contact, death during waiting for DST results, refusing enrollment and severe complications.

Key words: Tuberculosis, pulmonary, Tuberculosis, multidrug-resistant, Capital financing, Fees, medical, Treatment refusal